About the CAFE

CAFE (Climate-based Assessments and Forecasts for Ecosystems) Gulf of Maine was started in 2003 to explore the impact of interannual variability, especially climate variability, on the physical and biological conditions in the Gulf of Maine.

The blog is public, but you must be a member to post. To join, please email Andrew Pershing.

Nov 17, 2006

Going Forward

Here are some ideas for future work. Please add your ideas!
  1. An NCEAS working group to consider top-down vs. bottom-up issues.
  2. An article in EOS describing the workshop and our preliminary synthesis.
  3. A series of papers or special issue on the theme of Arctic influences on NW Atlantic
  4. Closer examination of late 90s anomalies, especially contrasting 1996 with 1998
  5. More rigorous comparison of CPR data from Newfoundland to Gulf of Maine and possibly Mid Atlantic Bight
  6. Analysis of the O18 data collected during GLOBEC. This is now in the database.
I plan to take a stab it item 2. Any volunteers for the others?

Arctic processes

There was considerable interest at the workshop in learning more about processes in the Arctic and whether/how they might be related to changes in the NW Atlantic. After the workshop, Bob Pickart sent me the following message:
First of all, I apologize for not knowing the full interpretation of the slide that I showed yesterday from Andrey. He clarified it to me as follows (you can read more about it in his 2002 GRL article that's posted on the blog): The red/blue timeseries is his model-derived Beaufort Gyre freshwater content index, it is not data. However, this index was "verified" using data from the 1970s. I put the word verified in quotes because the only data available for such a comparison was the 7 year time period from 1973-79. While the agreement between his model and the data was very good over that period, the Beaufort Gyre was essentially in the anti-cyclonic mode during that time. Obviously one would have liked to compare the model and data over both the anticyclonic and cyclonic phases, but this is not possible (too many data gaps in the EWG data base). So the bottom line is that the red/blue timeseries is a model-derived index. The thick black line in the figure is a lowpassed version of the index, and the other curve in the figure is the Arctic Oscillation index.

The other point that Andrey mentioned to me was the potential importance of ice-melt in forming the North Atlantic GSAs. We touched on this yesterday, but Andrey mentioned the following: During the anticyclonic phase of the winds, most of the ice export through Fram strait comes from the Eurasian side of the Arctic, whereas during the cyclonic phase much of it comes from the area north of Greenland. This latter region has much thicker ice and represents a greater pool of freshwater (once the ice melts downstream in the Nordic Seas and Irminger Sea). Andrey feels that this solid freshwater source is potentially as important as the liquid freshwater release from the Beaufort Gyre. Note that this ice-melt process concerns the Fram Strait route. It's not obvious to me about the ice flux through the archipelago, since much (all?) of it is land-fast for much of the year. We need to talk with someone like Humfrey Melling about the ice flux through the archipelago. I'm sure Humfrey's chapter in the upcoming ASOF book will shed a lot of light on this. I'll send you the list of chapter titles in the ASOF book shortly.

Comments on the Workshop

First, thanks to everyone who participated. I've received a lot of positive feedback on the workshop. I'll take credit for the food and coffee, but the intellectual quality was due to all of you. I hope we can continue the discussions via the blog, and hopefully, at future meetings. Below is a brief summary of my conclusions from the meeting. Please post corrections as comments.

The presentations and discussion on the first 1.5 days focused on the physical processes. Specifically, we focused on the origins of the low-salinity anomalies during the 1990s and how/when they appeared downstream. I think we all agree that there were low salinity anomalies during the early and late 1990s, with the late '90s anomaly appearing in two pulses ('96 and '98) in the Gulf of Maine and Mid Atlantic Bight. My sense was that we have better information on the early anomaly (e.g. Belkin's paper), but that the later anomalies are less well described. There is considerable uncertainty about how the early anomaly was generated (Beaufort Gyre relaxation? melting? river discharge?) and the path that it took (Fram Strait? Canadian Archipelago?); however, the general feeling was that it originated in the Arctic. Less is known about the late 90s anomalies. In the Gulf of Maine, we see a freshwater anomaly at the surface in both '96 and '98, while only the '98 signal appears at depth (the infamous LSSW). Off the shelf and in the MAB, both anomalies appear from surface to depths of >200m (?). The '98 LSSW event has been linked to the '96 negative NAO, which begs the question of how the '96 LSSW event was created, given that there was no preceeding NAO event.

Biologically, we see changes in the plankton community along the entire shelf during the 1990s. In the Gulf of Maine, there is a strong contrast between the salty '80s and fresh '90s, with conditions returning to 1980s-like around 2001. The hallmark of the 1990s shift is an increase in fall phytoplankton abundance and the abundance of most copepods, especially during the fall-winter period. The exception seems to be Calanus finmachicus, whose decrease in the 1990s has been attributed to herring predation. Plankton changes upstream, on the Scotian and Newfoundland Shelves, are broadly consistent with those in the Gulf of Maine, but the picture is complicated by the lack of data during the 1980s. Specifically, there is an increase in "cool season" phytoplankton and a corresponding increase in some of the smaller copepods, while C. finmarchicus declines. An interesting question is why the seasonal shift in phytoplankton concentrations between the regions?

Finally, we devoted the remaining time on day to discussions of top-down vs. bottom-up changes in ecosystems in the NW Atlantic. This discussion was motivated by the Frank et al. "trophic cascade" paper. The group was generally skeptical of these results, especially the contention that removal of cod has effects all the way down the food chain to nutrients. Most people did think the link between cod and their forage species was plausible. However, Graham presented some interesting data from the Newfoundland Shelf, showing that cod growth is currently food limited, despite high shrimp abundance. In Newfoundland, it appears that the reduction in capelin abundance is slowing the recovery of the code.

Participants

Here's the list of participants. Email and phone numbers will be sent via email.

Name Institution
Igor Belkin (URI)
Jim Bisagni (U. Mass.)
Anne-MarieBrunner (U. Mass.)
Cabell Davis (WHOI)
Heather Deese (U. Maine)
Ted Durbin (URI)
Susan Elston (U. Maine)
Charles Flagg (SUNY Stony)
Charles Greene (Cornell)
Sirpa Hakkinen (NASA Godda)
Erica Head (BIO)
Rita Heimes (USM)
Ross Hendry (BIO)
Lew Incze (USM)
Peter Jumars (U. Maine)
Louise McGarry (Cornell)
David Mountain (NEFSC)
Andrew Pershing (U. Maine)
Bob Pickart (WHOI)
Nathan Rebuck (U. Maine)
Jeffrey Runge (U. Maine/G)
Graham Sherwood (GMRI)
Peter Smith (BIO)
Phil Williamson(NERC)
Nick Wolffe (USM)
Yuying Zhang (U. Maine)

Test post

Smile awhile!

Nov 2, 2006

CAFE Workshop III: Agenda

Day 1: Arctic Climate Influences on NW Atlantic
  • 08:30--breakfast
  • 09:00--welcome & logistics (Pershing)
  • 09:10--introduction (Greene)
  • 09:20--overview talks
    • Igor Belkin (URI): GSA 90s
    • Bob Pickart (WHOI): Dynamics on E. Greenland Shelf/Slope
    • Anne-Marie Brenner (UMassD): Tracing Labrador Water w/ Satellites
    • Jim Bisagni (UMassD): Variations in Shelf-Slope Front
    • Erica Head (BIO): Interdecadal changes in plankton on Newfoundland and Central Scotian Shelves
  • 10:30--break
  • 10:50--discussion
  • 12:00--lunch
  • 12:45--discussion
  • 15:00--break
  • 15:30--wrap-up and summary
  • 17:00--adjourn
Day 2:Top-Down vs. Bottom-Up
  • 08:30--breakfast
  • 09:00--introduction (Pershing)
  • 09:10--overview talks
    • Graham Sherwood (GMRI): Dynamics of cod and capelin on Newfoundland Shelf
    • Erica Head (BIO): TDvBU issues on Newfoundland and Central Scotian Shelves
    • Andrew Pershing (U Maine): Salinty anomalies and Gulf of Maine regime shifts
  • 10:00--discussion
  • 10:30--break
  • 10:50--discussion
  • 12:00--lunch
  • 12:45--discussion summary and wrap-up
  • 15:00--adjourn

Oct 30, 2006

CAFE Workshop III

The third CAFE Workshop will be held on November 7-8 at the Gulf of Maine Research Institute in Portland, ME. The workshop will focus on the impact of Arctic climate variability on the Gulf of Maine and the importance of top-down vs. bottom-up processes in ecosystem changes. More information on these themes is below. Also, please look at the earlier posts for information on logistics, presentations, discussion questions, and reference papers. Please feel free to send me comments or questions, or better yet, post on the site.

The two major themes that we will explore are 1.) the role of remote forcing from the Labrador Sea and Arctic in driving ecosystem processes in the Northwest Atlantic (with a special focus on the Scotian Shelf, Gulf of Maine, Georges Bank, and Middle Atlantic Bight), and 2.) the role of climate-associated bottom-up forcing and fishing-associated top down forcing on ecosystem processes and regime shifts in the Northwest Atlantic. The first theme will be the focus of day 1 and may spill over into the morning of day 2. The second theme will be the focus of day 2.

With only two days available to us, we must not only be efficient, we must also be realistic about what we can expect to accomplish. Our major goal is not to depart from the meeting with all of the answers; rather, I hope that we will leave the meeting with a number of new and interesting questions. Ideally, we can establish some smaller groups to tackle these questions over the next year so that when we reconvene, we will have some answers as well as some important papers.

CAFE Workshop III: Logistics

Dates: Tuesday 11/7 and Wednesday 11/8

Location: TD Banknorth Boardroom
Gulf of Maine Research Institute
350 Commercial St.
Portland, ME
Enter through the Commercial St. doors, proceed to the third floor, and turn right. The Boardroom is the first door on the right in the hallway.

Parking: Park in the GMRI lot.

Coffee and pastries will be available at 8:30, and the meetings will run from 9-5.

CAFE Workshop III: Talks

We would like to keep formal presentations to a minimum. If you would like to give a brief presentation (5 minutes, 1-2 slides), please e-mail me.

CAFE Workshop III: Arctic Climate Influences (Day 1)

Here are three questions posed by Chuck (Greene) for consideration during day 1 of the workshop.

1.) What is the exact Arctic origin of the large salinity anomalies observed in the early 1990s and late 1990s in the Northwest Atlantic?

2.) Were the two pulses of low-salinity water we observed in the GOM/GB region during the late 1990s Pacific-derived, Summer Bering Sea Water that started in the Chukchi Sea in about 1990, crossed the Arctic in the Transpolar Drift, passed through Fram Strait, made the circuit around Greenland to the Labrador Sea via the East and West Greenland Currents, and then moved down the shelf all the way to the Middle Atlantic Bight.

3.) Does the Arctic Ocean move in and out of different circulation modes characterized by 1.) shallow freshwater export through the Canadian Archipelago and Fram Strait and 2.) freshwater storage in the Beaufort Gyre. There are tantalizing hints here and there that positive Arctic Oscillation (AO) conditions associated with strong cyclonic circulation in the atmosphere changes the Arctic Ocean circulation in a manner that opens up the flood gates (so to speak) through the Canadian Archipelago and Fram Strait. Less positive and negative AO conditions seem to strengthen the Beaufort Gyre and reduce the outflows, particularly of Pacific-derived shallow waters through the Canadian Archipelago (principally Coastal Alaskan Water) and Fram Strait (Summer Bering Sea Water and Coastal Alaskan Water).

CAFE Workshop III: Top-down vs. Bottom-up (Day 2)

Following Chuck's lead, I'd like to provide some discussion questions for day 2's theme, but before we get too far, we need to define what we mean by top-down vs. bottom-up (TDvBU) forcing. At one level, this is easy: top-down means the impact of a change in a predator population on lower trophic levels, while bottom-up means the impact of a change in a lower trophic level (usually, primary productivity, but could also include physical forcing) on higher trophic levels. There seem to be two distinct uses of TDvBU in the literature (the recent paper by Frank and colleagues does a nice job presenting this distinction). First, there is an "equillibrium" usage. In this case, people want to know the degree to which predation vs. production determine the structure of an ecosystem. Most of the time, this is silly--if there were no productivity, there would be no ecosystem, so everything is bottom-up at some level. However, Paine's concept of a keystone species, one whose presence/absence determines the presence/absence of other species, argues that top-down processes can determine the mean state of an ecosystem. Analogously, there is also a dynamical version of TDvBU. In this case, the question is whether a change in the abundance of a species was due to a change in its birth rate or in its mortality. For our purposes, I think the dynamical version is more appropriate. OK, here are the questions:


1. Are there particular characteristics of an ecosystem (productivity, diversity, etc.) that make it more sensitive to top-down vs. bottom-up processes?

2. How do changes in top-down forcing (for example, collapse of cod) interact with bottom-up forcing (for example, climate change)?

3. Is there a way to quantify the relative importance of changes in predation or production?

CAFE Workshop III: Reference papers

Here are the papers that were distributed by email and FTP. Please feel free to add to the list.
  • (PDF) Belkin, I. M., S. Levitus, J. Antonov, and S.-A. Malmberg. (1998) "Great Salinity Anomalies" in the North Atlantic. Progress in Oceanography 41:1-68.
  • (PDF) Belkin, I. M. (2004) Propagation of the "Great Salinity Anomaly" of the 1990s around the northern North Atlantic. Geophysical Research Letters 31:L08306.(color figs)
  • (PDF) Frank, K. T., B. Petrie, J. S. Choi, and W. C. Leggett. (2005) Trophic cascades in a formerly cod-dominated ecosystem. Science 308:1621-1623.
  • (PDF) Frank, K. T., B. Petrie, N. L. Shackell, and J. S. Choi. (2006) Reconciling differences in trophic control in mid-latitude marine ecosystems. Ecological Letters 9: 1-10.
  • (PDF) Greene, C. H. and A. J. Pershing (submitted) Arctic climate change and its impacts on the ecology of the North Atlantic. Ecology.
  • (PDF) Pershing, A. J., C. H. Greene, J. W. Jossi, L. O’Brien, J. K. T. Brodziak, and B. A. Bailey. (2005) Interdecadal variability in the Gulf of Maine zooplankton community with potential impacts on fish recruitment. ICES Journal of Marine Science 62:1511-1523
  • (PDF) Pershing , A. J., C. H. Greene, E. G. Durbin, E. J. H. Head, S. Häkkinen, D. G. Mountain, J. W. Jossi et al. (submitted) Ecosystem changes in the Gulf of Maine forced by North Atlantic freshening. Limnology & Oceanography.
  • (PDF) Proshutinsky A., R. H. Bourke, and F. A. McLaughlin, The role of the Beaufort Gyre in Arctic climate variability: Seasonal to decadal climate scales, Geophys. Res. Lett., 29 (23), 2100, doi:10.1029/2002GL015847, 2002.
  • Proshutinsky, A. Y., M. A. Johnson, Two circulation regimes of the wind-driven Arctic Ocean, J. Geophys. Res., 102(C6), 12493-12514, 10.1029/97JC00738, 1997.
  • (PDF) Dukhovskoy D. S., M. A. Johnson, A. Proshutinsky (2004), Arctic decadal variability: An auto-oscillatory system of heat and fresh water exchange, Geophys. Res. Lett., 31, L03302, doi:10.1029/2003GL019023.
  • Dukhovskoy D., M. Johnson, A. Proshutinsky (2006), Arctic decadal variability from an idealized atmosphere-ice-ocean model: 2. Simulation of decadal oscillations, J. Geophys. Res., 111, C06029, doi:10.1029/2004JC002820.

Sep 28, 2006

Why a blog?

Good question! I decided to set up a CAFE-based blog mainly out of frustration with other web-options available. Originally, there was a CAFE site at Cornell; however, an effort to "improve" the department's website resulted in all my links breaking (not to mention making the URLs printed on 100 coffee mugs obsolete). To avoid having the same thing happen at U Maine or GMRI, I decided to choose a format that I had more control over. Also, I hope that the blog will be easier to update and maintain, and might even be useful for doing some real work!